Information Services banner Edinburgh Research Archive The University of Edinburgh crest

Edinburgh Research Archive >
History, Classics and Archaeology, School of >
History and Classics PhD thesis collection >

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:

This item has been viewed 78 times in the last year. View Statistics

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
Cramond2011.pdfpdf final version1.27 MBAdobe PDFView/Open
Title: Motivation for creating the Museum of Scotland, and the educational effectiveness of its history content for the visiting public
Authors: Cramond, Ronald Duncan
Supervisor(s): Devine, Tom
Cameron, Ewen
Issue Date: Jun-2011
Publisher: The University of Edinburgh
Abstract: My aim was to investigate the motivation for creating the Museum of Scotland, and the educational effectiveness of its history content for the visiting public,. Part One examines the creation and purpose of the Museum of Scotland. What was its origin? Why have a Museum of Scotland at all? What was the motivation of the Trustees and staff who campaigned and raised funds for it, and created the displays? (This Part draws mostly on primary sources such as unpublished Trustee, Advisory Board, and Committee reports, minutes and papers, letters; and Hansard). Part Two summarises the views of academic authorities and museum practitioners on the role of museums in education and learning. Their writings parallel the change in thinking in NMS, described in Part One, from primarily just collection and conservation of objects, to a vision of displaying to the public the ‘Wealth’ of historical and cultural heritage that had been collected. (This Part is almost entirely based on secondary sources – published books and articles). Part Three analyses how far the displays, as actually mounted, embody the vision of the creators. What do visitors get from the labels, interpretation, audio guides, guided tours, and interactives? (This is based partly on personal observation of the displays, influenced by published authorities on display techniques, partly on personal discussions with several curators, and partly on access to an important, unpublished primary source – the minutes and papers of the Exhibition Review Committee which monitored the creation of the displays). Part Four discusses attempts to evaluate visitor reaction. This Part analyses reports on unpublished visitor surveys of ‘Special Exhibitions’ by the National Museums of Scotland, Glasgow Museums Service, Merseyside Museums and Galleries, and the Imperial War Museum (North). It also contains a completely new visitor survey of the Museum of Scotland displays, geared specifically to Generic Learning Outcomes. It was organised and undertaken by this researcher, with help from several NMS volunteer guides, who conducted some of the interviews. It was supplemented by discussions with visitors in ‘mini groups’ and by feedback from two history teachers about visits by their students. The overall conclusion is that visitors did indeed learn from good, object-based displays, but many visitors, even native Scots, had disappointingly little understanding of Scottish history before their visit.
Keywords: museum
Museum of Scotland
educational effectiveness
history content
visiting public
Appears in Collections:History and Classics PhD thesis collection

This item is licensed under a Creative Commons License
Creative Commons

Items in ERA are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.


Valid XHTML 1.0! Unless explicitly stated otherwise, all material is copyright © The University of Edinburgh 2013, and/or the original authors. Privacy and Cookies Policy