Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisorShackley, Simon
dc.contributor.authorZölls, Elisa
dc.date.accessioned2011-08-18T16:15:21Z
dc.date.available2011-08-18T16:15:21Z
dc.date.issued17/08/2011
dc.identifier.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/1842/5193
dc.description.abstractThis dissertation deals with the policy issues of large-scale, urban water privatisation projects in the face of uncertainty and variability. The main objective is to evaluate whether a single policy approach, namely privatisation associated with the Melamchi Water Supply Project, is appropriate in the face of a dynamic natural and cultural heterogeneity in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal. In line with this objective, the main research findings are that there are multiple policy debates, which appear to reflect competing perceptions of the legitimacy water crisis. However, the resolution of the debate over whose definition of the water problem prevails largely determines the policy outcome. With respect to this, Cultural Theory has been chosen as a heuristic device to provide some order to the different perceptions that were uncovered in the policy dispute. The key findings show that due to a market-oriented shift in the policy arena, the Melamchi Water Supply Project along with its privatisation scheme is considered by Nepal’s officials as the only alternative to water scarcity in the Kathmandu Valley. Yet, the analysis of the urban water project deduced that this singular policy approach would be ‘locked into’ a water-based technological design model through a path-dependent process, which makes it prone to delays and failures in the face of a dynamic, heterogeneous environment. Therefore, it is recommended instead to focus on ‘clumsy’, ‘resilient’ institutions in order to respond to internal and external constraints. That is, the Melamchi project and its private water market around the existing multiplicity of water service approaches in the Valley.en
dc.language.isoenen
dc.publisherThe University of Edinburghen
dc.subjectClumsy solutionsen
dc.subjectCultural Theoryen
dc.subjectKathmandu Valleyen
dc.subjectlock-inen
dc.subjectMelamchi Water Supply Projecten
dc.subjectNepalen
dc.subjectwater privatisationen
dc.subjectMSc Environment, Culture and Societyen
dc.titleWater Privatisationen
dc.title.alternativeA Single Water Policy Approach in the Face of Uncertainty and Variabilityen
dc.typeThesis or Dissertationen
dc.relation.referencesAgarwal, A. and Narain, S. (1997) Dying wisdom: the decline and revival of traditional water harvesting systems in India The Ecologist 27 (3), 112-216.en
dc.relation.referencesArthur, W. B. (1989) Completing Technologies, Increasing Returns, and Lock-In by Historical Events The Economic Journal 99, 116-131.en
dc.relation.referencesAryal, M. (2007) Private water, public debate. Nepali Times [online]. (Issue #335) Available at: http://www.nepalitimes.com/issue/335/Nation/13217 [Accessed 21 March 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesAsian Development Bank (ADB) (2008) Nepal: Melamchi Water Supply Project and Kathmandu Valley Water Services Sector Development Programme [online]. ADB. Available at: http://www.adb.org/Documents/Loan-Major-Changes-Scope/NEP/31624-NEP-MCS.pdf [Accessed 8 April 2011].en
dc.relation.references-----(2000) Report and Recommendation of the President to the Board of Directors on a Proposed Loan to the Kingdom of Nepal for the Melamchi Water Supply Project [online]. (RRP: NEP 31624) ADB. Available at: http://www.adb.org/Documents/RRPs/NEP/31624-NEP-RRP.pdf [Accessed 7 April 2011].en
dc.relation.references-----(1998) Technical Assistance (Financed form the Japan Special Fund) to the Kingdom of Nepal for Urban Water Supply Reforms in Kathmandu Valley [online]. (TAR: NEP 31620) ADB. Available at: http://www.adb.org/Documents/TARs/NEP/31620-NEP-TAR.pdf [Accessed 10 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesBabel, M. S., Gupta, A. D., and Pradhan, P. (2007) A multivariate econometric approach for domestic water demand modelling: An application to Kathmandu, Nepal Water Resource Manage 21, 573-589.en
dc.relation.referencesBäckstrand, K. (2003) Civil Science for Sustainability: Reframing the Role of Experts, Policy-Makers and Citizens in Environmental Governance Global Environmental Politics 3(4), 24-41.en
dc.relation.referencesBarlösius, E., Scheumann, W., and Sikor, T. (2008) Introduction: Public-Private Relations and Key Policy Issues in Natural Resource Governance, in T. Sikor (ed.) Public and private in natural resource governance: a false dichotomy? Earthscan, UK and USA.en
dc.relation.referencesBajracharya, D., Etherington, A., and Wicken, J. (2003) Preparing for Private Sector Management in Kathmandu: New Rules, New Roles: Does PSP benefit the poor? [online]. WaterAid and Tearfund. Available at: http://www.wateraid.org/documents/plugin_documents/pspnepal.pdf [Accessed 21 March 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesBajracharya, P. and Manandhar, N. (2000) Privatisation in Nepal, in G. Joshi (ed.) Privatization in South Asia: Minimizing Negative Social Effects through Restructuring. International Labour Organization, India.en
dc.relation.referencesBakker, K. (2007) The “Commons” Versus the “Commodity”: Alter-globalisation, Anti-privatisation and the Human Right to Water in the Global South Antipode, 430-455.en
dc.relation.references-----(2003) A Political Ecology of Water Privatisation Studies in Political Economy 70, 35-58.en
dc.relation.referencesBasnet, G., Bhattarai, M., and Pant, D. (2008) Implications of Bulk Water Transfer on Local Water Management Institutions: A Case Study of the Melamchi Water Supply Project in Nepal. (Working Paper No. 78) CAPRi, Washington.en
dc.relation.referencesBaumert, J. and Bloodgood, L. (2004) Private Sector Participation in the Water and Wastewater Services Industry. (No. ID-08) U.S. International Trade Commission, Washington DC.en
dc.relation.referencesBerkoff, J. and Molle, F. (2009) Cities vs. agriculture: A review of intersectoral water re-allocation Natural Resources Forum 33, 6-18.en
dc.relation.referencesBhattarai, M, Molden, D., and Pant, D. (2002) Socio-Economics and Hydrological Impacts of Intersectoral and Interbasin Water Transfer Decisions: Melamchi Water Transfer Project in Nepal [online]. Available at: http://www.forum-adb.org/BACKUP/pdf/PDF-melamchi/8.%20IWMI%20Study%20on%20Melamchi%20Water%20Sharing%20April%202002.pdf [Accessed 2 February 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesBohara, A. K. and Katuwal, H. (2007) Coping with Unreliable Water Supplies and Willingness to Pay for Improved Water Supplies in Kathmandu, Nepal [online]. Albuquerque, New Mexico: University of New Mexico. Available at: http://repository.unm.edu/bitstream/handle/1928/3315/HariKatuwal_CopingWaterWTPpdf.pdf?sequence=1 [Accessed 10 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesBrittan, S. S. (1998) Challenges to the welfare state, in H. Cavanna (ed.) Challenges to the welfare state: internal and external dynamics for change. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham and Northampton.en
dc.relation.referencesBrook, D. (2001) The ongoing tragedy of the commons The Social Science Journal 38, 611-616.en
dc.relation.referencesBuck, S. J. (1989) Cultural Theory and Management of Common Property Resources Human Ecology 17(1), 101-116.en
dc.relation.referencesBudds, J. and McGranahan, G. (2003) Are the debates on water privatization missing the point? Experiences from Africa, Asia and Latin America Environment and Urbanization 15(2), 89-113.en
dc.relation.referencesCampbell, B. (2007) Resisting the Environmentalist State, in D. Gellner (ed.) Resistance and the State: Nepalese Experiences. Berghahn Books, New York and Oxford.en
dc.relation.referencesCarangal-San Jose, M. J. F. and Gunatilake, H. (2008) Privatisation Revisited: Lessons from Private Sector Participation in Water Supply and Sanitation in Developing Countries. (ERD Working Paper No. 115) ADB, Metro Manila.en
dc.relation.referencesCastree, N. (2001) Socializing Nature: Theory, Practice, and Politics, in B. Braun and N. Castree (eds.) Social Nature: Theory, Practice, and Politics. Blackwell, Oxford and Malden.en
dc.relation.referencesChapagain, D. P., Gartaula, H., Khatri-Chhetri, J. B., and Pant, D. (2006) Governance and Economics of Urban Water Transfer: A case study of Melamchi Intersectoral Water Transfer Project in Nepal [online]. Kathmandu, Nepal: Centre for Policy Analysis and Development Nepal. Available at: http://www.saneinetwork.net/pdf/SANEI_VII/project_9.pdf [Accessed 22 January 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesCollingridge, D. (1992) The management of scale: big organisations, big technologies, big mistakes. Routledge, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesCorral, V. P. (2007) NEPAL WATER PRIVATIZATION: Role of ADB and PSI’s call for Quality Water Services and Public Water Management. Public Services International Research Unit. Available at: http://www.waterjustice.org/uploads/attachments/2_ADB_Water-privatization_Nepal_vpc_kyoto_may07_eng.pdf [Accessed 28 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesDellapenna, J. W. (2009) The Market Alternative in J. W. Dellapenna and J. Gupta (eds.) The Evolution of the Law and Politics of Water. Springer Science + Business Media B. V., Villanova.en
dc.relation.referencesDixit, A. and Gyawali, D. (2001) Water and science: hydrological uncertainties, developmental aspirations and uningrained scientific culture Futures 33, 689-708.en
dc.relation.referencesDixit, A., Janakarajan, S., Moench, M., Mudrakartha, S., and Rathore, M. S. (2003) The Fluid Mosaic: Water Governance in the Context of Variability, Uncertainty and Change [online]. Kathmandu, Nepal: Nepal Water Conservation Foundation. Available at: http://www.idrc.ca/uploads/user-S/10492953541Fluid_Mosaic21.pdf [Accessed 22 March 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesDouglas, M., Ellis. R., Engel, C., Hendriks, F., Lohmann, S., Ney, S., Rayner, S., Thompson, M., and Verweij, M. (2006) The Case of Clumsiness, in M. Thompson and M. Verweij (eds.) Clumsy Solutions for A Complex World: Governance, Politics and Plural Perceptions. Palgrave MacMillan, New York.en
dc.relation.referencesEllis, R., Thompson, M., and Wildavsky, A. (1990) Cultural Theory. Westview Press, Colorado and Oxford.en
dc.relation.referencesGartaula, H., Bhattarai, M., Khatri-Chhetri, J., Chapagain, D. P., and Dhakal, S. (2008) Selected Policy Issues and Discourses in Implementing the Melamchi Water Supply Project in Nepal [online]. Available at: http://www.iwra.org/congress/2008/resource/authors/abs626_article.pdf [Accessed 1 February 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesGiddens, A. (1998) The Future of the Welfare State, in M. Novak (ed.) Is There a Third Way? Essays on the changing direction of socialist thought. (No. 46) The IEA Health and Welfare, London.en
dc.relation.referencesGlobal Trade Negotiations Homepage: Centre for International Development at Harvard (2003) Washington Consensus [online]. Available at: http://www.cid.harvard.edu/cidtrade/issues/washington.html [Accessed 11 May 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesGrafton, R. Q. (2000) Governance of the Commons: A Role for the State? Land Economics 76(4), 504-517.en
dc.relation.referencesGrendstad, G., Selle, P., and Thompson, M. (1999) Cultural theory as political science, in G. Grendstad, P. Selle, and M. Thompson (eds.) Cultural Theory as Political Science. Routledge, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesGyawali, D. (dipakgyawali@ntc.net.np), 20 April 2011. Re: Water Privatisation – MWSP. E-Mail to E. Zölls (elisazoells@hotmail.com).en
dc.relation.references-----(2006) Hype and Hydro (and, at Last, Some Hope) in the Himalaya, in M. Thompson and M. Verweij (eds.) Clumsy Solutions for A Complex World: Governance, Politics and Plural Perceptions. Palgrave MacMillan, New York.en
dc.relation.referencesHachhethu, K. (2007) Nepali Politics: People-Parties Interface, in D. Gellner (ed.) Resistance and the State: Nepalese Experiences. Berghahn Books, New York and Oxford.en
dc.relation.referencesHardin, G. (1968) The Tragedy of the Commons Science 162, 1343-1348.en
dc.relation.referencesHaque, M. S. (2001) The Diminishing Publicness of Public Service under the Current Mode of Governance Public Administration Review 61(1), 65-82.en
dc.relation.referencesHatley, T., Thompson, M., and Warburton, M. (2007) Uncertainty on a Himalayan Scale. Himal Books, London.en
dc.relation.referencesHeynen, N. and Robbins, P. (2005) The neoliberalisation of nature: Governance, privatization, enclosure and valuation Capitalism Nature Socialism 16(1), 5-8.en
dc.relation.referencesInoue, M., Khatiwada, N.R., Takizawa, S., and Tran, T.V.N. (2002) Groundwater contamination assessment for sustainable water supply in Kathmandu Valley, Nepal Water Science and technology 46 (9), 147-154.en
dc.relation.referencesJoerges, B. (1999) Do Politics Have Artefacts? Social Studies of Science 29(3), 411-431.en
dc.relation.referencesJohnston, B. R. (2003) The Political Ecology of Water: An Introduction CNS 14(3), 73-90.en
dc.relation.referencesJordan, A., Wurzel, R. K. W., and Zito, A. R (2003) ‘New’ Instruments of Environmental Governance: Patterns and Pathways of Change Environmental Politics 12(1), 1-24.en
dc.relation.referencesKikeri, S. and Nellis, J. (1989) Public Enterprise Reform: Privatisation and the World Bank World Development 17(5), 659-672.en
dc.relation.referencesKluge, T. and Scheele, U. (2008) Private Sector Participation in Water Supply and Sanitation: A Contribution to Attaining the Millennium Development Goals or Merely the Export of Old Solutions? in W Scheumann et al. (eds.) Water Politics and Development Cooperation. Springer, Berlin and Heidelberg.en
dc.relation.referencesKuhnle, S. (1998) Political reconstruction of the European welfare states, in H. Cavanna (ed.) Challenges to the welfare state: internal and external dynamics for change. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham and Northampton.en
dc.relation.referencesKumar, K. C. B., Pattanyaka, S. K., Whittington, D., and Yang, J.-C. (2005) Coping with unreliable public water supplies: Averting expenditures by households in Kathmandu, Nepal Water Resource Research 41, 1-11.en
dc.relation.referencesLloyd, J. (1998) Serf No More, in M. Novak (ed.) Is There a Third Way? Essays on the changing direction of socialist thought. (No. 46) The IEA Health and Welfare, London.en
dc.relation.referencesLund, C. and Sikor, T. (2009) Access and Property: A Question of Power and Authority Development and Change 40(1), 1-22.en
dc.relation.referencesMamadouh, V. (1999) Grid-group cultural theory: an introduction GeoJournal 47(3), 395-409.en
dc.relation.referencesMatzner, E. (1998) The crisis of the welfare state: a game-theoretic interpretation, in H. Cavanna (ed.) Challenges to the welfare state: internal and external dynamics for change. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham and Northampton.en
dc.relation.referencesMolenaers, N. and Thompson, M. (1999) The cultural conditions for democracy and their implications for transitional societies, in G. Grendstad, P. Selle, and M. Thompson (eds.) Cultural Theory as Political Science. Routledge, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesMorgan, B. (2006) Turning Off the Tap: Urban Water Service Delivery and the Social Construction of Global Administrative Law The European Journal of International Law 17(1), 215-246.en
dc.relation.referencesNepal Water Conservation Foundation. Activities [online]. Available at: http://www.nwcf.org.np/activities.html [Accessed 12 June 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesNepal Water for Health. About Us [online]. Available at: http://www.newah.org.np/about/about.php [Accessed 12 June 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesNewman, M. (2005) Socialism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesNey, S. and Thompson, M. (1999) Consulting the frogs: the normative implications of Cultural Theory, in G. Grendstad, P. Selle, and M. Thompson (eds.) Cultural Theory as Political Science. Routledge, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesNovak, M. (1998) The Crisis of Social Democracy, in M. Novak (ed.) Is There a Third Way? Essays on the changing direction of socialist thought. (No. 46) The IEA Health and Welfare, London.en
dc.relation.referencesOrmerod, P. (1998) The Traditions of Social Democracy, in M. Novak (ed.) Is There a Third Way? Essays on the changing direction of socialist thought. (No. 46) The IEA Health and Welfare, London.en
dc.relation.referencesPanday, R. K. (2003) Water and Cultural Diversity in Nepal, in UNESCO/Water Academy (ed.) Proceedings of the Theme: Water and Cultural Diversity. UNESCO/Water Academy, Kyoto.en
dc.relation.referencesPaudel, H. (2006) The Implementation of Privatisation Policy: Case Studies from Nepal [online]. Bonn, Germany: ULB Bonn. Available at: http://hss.ulb.uni-bonn.de:90/2006/0724/0724.pdf [Accessed 15 March 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesPrivatisation Act, 2050 (1994). Nepal: Government of Nepal: Ministry of Finance. Available at: http://www.privat.gov.np/act.html [Accessed 12 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesRanjitkar, S. B. (1996) Development Efforts In Nepal: A Historical Perspective. Ekta Books, Kathmandu.en
dc.relation.referencesRamamurti, R. (1992) Why Are Developing Countries Privatizing? Journal of International Business Studies 23(2), 225-249.en
dc.relation.referencesRasheed, K. B. S. (1995) Nepal’s Water Resources: the Potential for Exploitation in the Upper Ganges Catchment, in G. P. Chapman and M. Thompson (eds.) Water and the Quest for Sustainable Development in the Ganges Valley. Mansell, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesRees, J. A. (1998) Regulation and Private Participation in the Water and Sanitation Sector [online]. (Background Papers No. 1) Global Water Partnership: Technical Advisor Committee. Available at: http://info.worldbank.org/etools/docs/library/80636/IWRM4_TEC01-RegnAndPPInWatsan.pdf? [Accessed 11 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesSanwal, M. (1989) What We Know about Mountain Development: Common Property, Investment Priorities, and Institutional Arrangements Mountain Research and Development 9(1), 3-14.en
dc.relation.referencesSchwarz, M. and Thompson, M. (1990) Divided we stand: redefining politics, technology and social choice. Harvester Wheatsheaf, UK.en
dc.relation.referencesShrestha, R. S. (2008) Modifying Melamchi – Single Purpose vs. Multipurpose. RathnaSansar Shrestha, FCA [online]. Available at: http://www.ratnasansar.com/2008/10/modifying-melamchi-single-purpose-vs.html [Accessed 22 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesSwyngedouw, E. (2005) Dispossessing H2O: the contested terrain of water privatization Capitalism Nature Socialism 16(1), 81-98.en
dc.relation.referencesTam, H. B. (1998) Communitarianism: A New Agenda For Politics And Citizenship. McChillan Press, London.en
dc.relation.referencesThe Dublin Statement on Water and Sustainable Development, 1992. World Meteorological Organisation, Dublin. Available at: http://www.un-documents.net/h2o-dub.htm [Accessed 16 April 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesThompson, M. (2008) Organising & Disorganising: A Dynamic and Non-Linear Theory of Institutional Emergence and its Implications. Triarchy Press, Devon.en
dc.relation.references-----(1995) Policy-making in the face of Uncertainty: the Himalayas as Unknowns, in G. P. Chapman and M. Thompson (eds.) Water and the Quest for Sustainable Development in the Ganges Valley. Mansell, London and New York.en
dc.relation.referencesThompson, M. and Warburton, M. (1985) Knowing Where to Hit It: A conceptual Framework for the Sustainable Development of the Himalaya Mountain Research and Development 5(3); 203-220.en
dc.relation.references-----(1985) Decision Making under Contradictory Certainties: how to save the Himalayas when you can’t find out what’s wrong with them Journal of Applied Systems analysis 12, 3-34.en
dc.relation.references-----(1985) Uncertainty on a Himalayan Scale Mountain Research and Development 5(2), 115-135.en
dc.relation.referencesUnited Nation Development Programme (UNDP) (2006) Human Development Report 2006: Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis [online]. UNDP, New York. Available at: http://hdr.undp.org/en/media/HDR06-complete.pdf [Accessed 7 May 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesUnruh, G. C. (2000) Understanding carbon lock-in Energy Policy 28, 817-830.en
dc.relation.referencesUpreti, B. R. (2007) Changing Political context, New Power Relations and Hydro-conflict in Nepal Nepal Water Security Forum. Uppsala University, Sweden: The Silk Road Studies Program, 1-25.en
dc.relation.referencesWater Supply and Sewerage Service Situation Study Committee (1987) Study Notes (appended to the actual report in Nepali). HMGN, Kathmandu.en
dc.relation.referencesWaterAid (2005) Water Laws in Nepal: Laws Relating to Drinking Water, Sanitation, Irrigation, Hydropower and Water Pollution [online]. WaterAid Nepal. Available at: http://www.wateraid.org/documents/plugin_documents/water_laws_in_nepal_english__february_2005.pdf [Accessed 12 May 2011].en
dc.relation.references-----(2004) The Water and Sanitation Millennium Development Targets in Nepal: What do they mean? What will they cost? Can Nepal meet them? [online]. WaterAid Nepal. Available at: http://www.wateraid.org/documents/plugin_documents/wan_mdg_report__september_2004.pdf [Accessed 21 March 2011].en
dc.relation.referencesWinner, L. (1980) Do Artifacts Have Politics? Daedalus, 109(1), 121-136.en
dc.type.qualificationlevelMastersen
dc.type.qualificationnameMSc Master of Scienceen
dcterms.accessRightsRestricted Accessen_US


Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record